Judicial principle — Kuwait Court of Cassation

Kuwait Court of Cassation principle number 1151

State of Kuwait · Criminal Procedure · Ministry of Justice — Court of Cassation — Technical Office

English translation of the principle

Draft judgment. It must be signed by all judges of the panel who heard the pleadings and participated in deliberation and issuance of the judgment. The reason therefor. Ensuring that the judgment is issued after deliberation encompassing its reasons and operative part. Contravention thereof. Its effect. Nullity of the draft and of the judgment rendered on its basis. - The appellate judgment's reference, in its reasons and operative part, to the first-instance judgment that is void because its draft was signed by the presiding judge of the panel that rendered it without its other 2 members. Its effect. Its nullity, even if it states reasons of its own. The reason therefor. What is founded on a nullity is itself void.
Arabic original
مسودة الحكم. وجوب التوقيع عليها من جميع قضاة الهيئة الذين سمعوا المرافعة واشتركوا في المداولة وإصدار الحكم. علة ذلك. ضمان صدور الحكم بعد مداولة شملت أسبابه ومنطوقه. مخالفة ذلك. أثره. بطلانها وبطلان الحكم الصادر بناء عليها. - إحالة الحكم الاستئنافي في أسبابه ومنطوقه إلى الحكم الابتدائي الباطل لتوقيع مسودته من رئيس الهيئة التي أصدرته دون عضويها الآخرين. أثره. بطلانه ولو أورد أسباباً خاصة به. علة ذلك. ما بني على باطل فهو باطل.
Original Arabic judgment citations

(الطعن ١٨١/٢٠٠٠ جزائي جلسة ٦/٢/٢٠٠١ القسم الرابع المجلد الثامن ص٣٧)

Source: Court of Cassation legal principles collection — Criminal Procedure — Ministry of Justice — Court of Cassation — Technical Office. Printed page 371. PDF pages: 364.

Ask the assistant about this principle

Guidance based on the principle and its source details, separate from the original collection text.

Related principles

Continue your case in the legal workspace

Open legal workspace