Judicial principle — Kuwait Court of Cassation

Kuwait Court of Cassation principle number 3719

State of Kuwait · Commercial and Labour — Volume 9 · Ministry of Justice — Court of Cassation — Technical Office

English translation of the principle

The insurer under compulsory insurance against motor vehicle accidents and the liable person are bound by the same debt despite its different sources. Effect thereof: their concurrent liability for its payment. Payment of the debt by the former constitutes payment of the latter’s debt, and the former is subrogated by operation of law to the injured party’s rights against the liable person. - A joint and several obligation has a single source, whereas a concurrent obligation has multiple sources despite having the same subject matter. Both types coincide regarding the effect of payment in terms of subrogation by operation of law. Reason therefor. - The insurer is a debtor vis-à-vis the insured or the injured party and a guarantor or surety vis-à-vis the liable person. Effect thereof. Its subrogation by operation of law to the injured party’s rights if it pays him the debt, and its entitlement to recourse against the liable person. - When subrogation by operation of law enjoys a prohibition relating to public policy and if the liable person is a relative or relative by marriage of the insured sharing the same household with him, or is someone for whose acts the insurer is responsible. Reason therefor. Example.
Arabic original
المؤمن في التأمين الإجباري عن حوادث السيارات والمسؤول التزامهما يكون بنفس الدين رغم اختلاف مصدره. أثر ذلك تضاممهما في الوفاء به. وفاء أولهما بالدين هو وفاء بدين الثاني ويحل حلولاً قانونياً محل المضرور قبل المسؤول. - الالتزام التضامني مصدره واحد بينما الالتزام التضاممي متعدد المصادر رغم وحدة محله. اتفاق النوعين فيما يتعلق بأثر الوفاء من حيث الحلول القانوني. علة ذلك. - المؤمن مدين قبل المؤمن له أو المضرور وضامن أو كفيل قبل المسؤول. أثر ذلك. حلوله محل المضرور حلولاً قانونياً إذا وفاه بالدين ويكون له الرجوع على المسؤول. - متى يتمتع الحلول القانوني منعاً يتعلق بالنظام العام وإذا كان المسؤول قريباً أو صهراً للمؤمن له ممن يكونون معه في معيشة واحدة أو يكون المؤمن مسؤولاً عن أعماله. علة ذلك. مثال.
Original Arabic judgment citations

(الطعن ١٤٥/١٩٨٨ تجاري جلسة ٣٠/١٠/١٩٨٨ مج القسم الثاني - المجلد الثالث ص ١٠٢٤)

Source: Court of Cassation legal principles collection — Commercial and Labour — Volume 9 — Ministry of Justice — Court of Cassation — Technical Office. Printed page 628. PDF pages: 628.

Ask the assistant about this principle

Guidance based on the principle and its source details, separate from the original collection text.

Related principles

Continue your case in the legal workspace

Open legal workspace